List Pages Lose Search On Back

Hello,

Is there a setting in Umbraco to have the child of a list page have a back button to return to the parent page with the search you did still in place?

e.g.

1000 news item
I search for chocolate
It returns 20 pages
I go to page 5
I select a news item
I want to go back but I cannot
And when I hit the browser back button I am back at page 1 with and the search/filter is undone.
And the tree on the left when I am looking at the news item is not indicative of my search.

Or is this a new implementation of Umbraco 17 that won’t change?

Actually, I just noticed the browser back button takes you back to the tab you last clicked :frowning: Not back up a level. Man. That’s going to confuse a lot of clients :frowning:

Hi @bythewiseman

If you’re able to confirm how this used to work in v13, it may be worth raising this as a regression if the behaviour has changed in v17.

It does sound like it may confuse a lot of people!

Justin

For example, my college website:

I search for HNC:

And then select page 7:

image

And select any course on page 7:

image

You can see the back button which takes me back to exactly where I was prior to selecting the node. And the node in the tree on the left stays rock solid and doesn’t change as it has been told to be a list view.

image

But Umbraco 17 wants to show me nodes that have no relevancy to what I am doing (different site in the next thumbnail) :

A lot of extra processing time/power used up to change the tree when there was no need to as it the News node here in this U17 website is has a list view.

We are only a few months away from U13 being EOL, and there is so much I feel is wrong/missing in U17. I know we had to get away from angular for good reasons, but U17 still to me feels like some got a blank sheet of paper and a very basic understanding of Umbraco and tried to re-write it, when U13’s look and feel and functionality was (imho) almost perfect!

PS I try not to raise too many bugs these days. There are folks that have an idea of how they want U17 and the future of Umbraco to go and they close down issues faster than I can blink these days, saying things like “well it works fine on my machine”. And it has become very disheartening to try to help out.

Hi @bythewiseman

If you can recreate this consistently and it’s not related to your custom code or a third-party package, then it definitely sounds like a bug. From a user perspective I would expect the back button to take you back to where you were before, including with filters and pagination preserved.

Definitely raise it.

Justin

But that’s the thing, the back button has been removed. It’s not a bug. It’s a feature of the new UI to not have a back button, it feels like.

To note specifically on returning to a Collection (old List View), we have recently fixed this for the next minor (17.7 / 18.2, out mid-September). It’ll remember the view, filter, ordering and pagination.

With the back button, I’d recommend raising an issue on the tracker. I appreciate that you may feel disheartened, (and I’m not sure which past issues you’re referring to), but I can say that at HQ we definitely take the time to digest all feedback. In the case of Collections, we’ve been iterating on the feature based on community feedback. I’m not saying it’s perfect, but we are listening.